Volume 14, Number1
February 2003 Copyright
2003 CRITERIUM ENGINEERS
![]()
The Engineering Advisor is intended to enhance your
knowledge of technical issues relating to buildings. For additional information on any subject, please feel free to
call us. Our commitment is to provide
you with timely, accurate information.
![]()
|
CABLING CONSIDER- ATIONS FOR
NETWORKS AND TELE-COMMUNI-CATIONS |
The condition and appropriateness of the cabling within
a building is almost always an afterthought for owners and tenants alike,
according to Tom Wales, a Telcom consultant.
This is true despite the growing importance of telecommunications and
power systems in buildings. According
to Dennis St. Jean, of Graybar Electric, the telecommunications department of
this 100-year old electrical supply company has grown to equal the size of
the conventional power supply division just in the last ten years. Yet building owners pay relatively little attention to
these systems when purchasing a building, assuming it is the tenant who will
be responsible anyway. And most
tenants don’t yet have the sophistication to anticipate their cabling needs
before signing a lease. These systems
are analagous to the circulatory and nervous systems of the human body. Without them, the building dies. When connections fail, the building
deteriorates, a condition that might be compared to senility. |
|
Types of cable |
Three types of cable predominate. Copper wire is the most common. The old CAT 1 cable that we are all
familiar with, used for phone lines, has been replaced with faster and faster
unshielded twisted pair (UTP) cable.
This cable also replaced coaxial cable in most workplaces. Today, however, fiber optic cable is the
preferred choice for speed, space, and security. Wireless connections are becoming more common between computers
and their hosts, but the communications backbone is still cable. Some of the old issues regarding safety and durability
remain concerns with fiber optic cables as well. Because they are glass, many assume that they are not
susceptible to lightning strikes. But
because they often have a metal central member, fiber optic cables may be as
susceptible as any other cable.
Surprisingly, fiber optic cable also deteriorates when wet. As a result, where the cable enters the
building and how it is protected is an important consideration. |
|
What does a PCA
cover? |
Most companies, as part of their due diligence, will
order a Property Condition Assessment (PCA) before they purchase a
building. Cabling systems, however,
are not normally covered by engineering firms conducting such
assessments. These systems are also
excluded from ASTM Standard 2018-99 that covers most PCAs. It is not realistic to assess telecommunications
systems as part of a PCA, partly because technology changes so fast. New technologies like Power Line
Communication (PLC) may make old cabling systems obsolete. In a standard PCA, there are some covered areas,
however, that may be helpful in evaluating these systems. Most office buildings of any size will
have a room (or closet) dedicated to telecommunications equipment and
electrical switchgear. Some larger
buildings in fact may have one such room on each floor. The condition of those rooms is an
important indication of the condition of the systems. ¨ Is
the space conditioned? We have found
examples of such rooms that are not part of the conditioned space. Exposure to extremes of heat, cold, and
moisture take their toll on such systems. ¨ Is
the space clean and orderly? Very
often, this space is used as additional storage space. Boxes, spare furniture, even trash often
block access. That is a good sign
that the systems have not been maintained. ¨ Are
there service contracts? Buildings
large enough for a separate room for switchgear and telcom equipment should
also have contracts to maintain that equipment. Are contracts in place and what is the service history? |
|
Problems with
cabling |
Telecommunications
cabling has special considerations. ¨
Has
the cable been stretched? Cables are
rated with tensile strength less than most electrical cables. Electricians used to pulling cable through
conduit and chases may apply too much pressure which, in turn, causes a
degradation in cable performance. ¨
Has
the cable been bent? Telcom cable,
especially fiber optic cable, have limits on the bending radius that may be
used. Fiber optic cables may not be
bent in diameters less than 40X the diameter of the cable itself. Overbending causes degradation as well. ¨
Is
the cable near devices that cause electro-magnetic inteference? These include copiers, monitors, power
supplies, UPS units, electric heaters, printers, TVs, fluorescent lights,
power cables, transformers, compressors, microwaves, etc. ¨
Is
the cable properly shielded?
Telecommunications cable should not be run in the same conduit as
power cables. ¨
Does
the cable have the correct fire rating?
Cables run in plenums (ceilings or under floors) must be of the
Communications Plenum (CMP) type, not the less expensive riser cable (CMR). ¨
Is
it hung correctly? Plastic hangers
and cable ties should be used. The
cable ties should be snug without being overtightened. |
|
What should a
buyer/owner look for? |
The buyer of an existing building may want to
know what type of cabling is installed.
If possible, both the buyer and tenant will want to avoid running new
cable. Since most transmission losses
occur at the connections or as a result of devices, these can generally be
upgraded without replacing the cable. Buyers and owners should investigate when the
cable was installed and when it was last upgraded. If you cannot read the cable type from the jacket, tracing with
pencil and paper (similar to grave rubbings) may reveal the type of cable
installed. It is also important to
know where the service entrance is (aerial or ground) and whether there is
room to pull more cable. Another
consideration is the redundancy in the system. If one floor goes out, does the whole building go out. |
|
What does a tenant
want to know? |
Tenants are also concerned with the cabling in
place. If fiber optic cable has been
installed, they are way ahead of the game.
However, most buildings still have copper wire. The current state of the art is referred
to as CAT 5, 5e, or 6. These
categories refer to the speed of data transmission, with CAT 5 rated for
100Mbps, and CAT 5e and 6 rated for 1000Mbps. CAT 3, rated for 10Mbps, is still serviceable, however, since
most computing equipment except for the very fastest systems, can use this
adequately. |
|
How does one
evaluate telcom and network cable? |
Many of the above-referenced conditions can be
evaluated by eye. But the true test
of cabling is not what it looks like, but how it performs. Quality cable, properly installed, should
be capable of transmitting data at 10 Mbps to 100 Mbps (million bits per second). . Tools are now available to measure this
throughput. In fact, the best
installers will actually guarantee throughput for the life of the
system. Obtaining such guarantees is
one way to improve the marketability of the space. |
|
Who can help? |
With the industry changing so rapidly, it is
possible to hire consultants to help you evaluate your communications
systems. These can be found in the
phone book or through equipment suppliers.
Your local phone utility company representative is often an excellent
place to start. The web site www.cablingdb.com
may also be useful. Criterium Engineers can also help coordinate this service as part of our total building
evaluation services. |
|
|
CRITERIUM ENGINEERS
22
Monument Square, Suite 600 Portland,
ME 04101 800/242-1969 |